Performed my own Mr. Gasket Thermostat test
Posted: Sun May 25, 2008 4:38 am
We had touched on this briefly before, but I don't remember where, and I won't whore anyone's thread up. Anyways, I was assembling the 383 in the Camaro, and I got to the thermostat housing. I figured I'd toss it in a pot of boiling water, since we've talked about it before. The one in this motor was an old example, the Mr. Gasket high-flow type, 160*. We've had the engine for about 4 years, and it sat for years before that, so no idea of the actual age. But I did know the age of the other Mr. Gasket high-flow thermostat I had laying around, 160* as well. This was the one I had in the Astre for a total mileage of about 10 miles. Strangely enough, the low miles were... because I would ALWAYS overheat!!!
So anyways... now I have this boiling pot, and two near identical Mr. Gasket thermostats. Once the water reaches 190*, I drop them in! Instantly, the old thermostat opens right up, completely open like it should. The NEW one however... wouldn't open up a crack! I let it sit for about 5 minutes, and no opening.
So this pisses me off. I'd expect a good product from a company like Mr. Gasket. I would think something as simple as a thermostat shouldn't have any issues. I know outsourcing is the rage now... but come on... they can't even build a decent thermostat that opens when it should? So now I'm thinking... my whole overheating issue before... where I'd reach 240* in a matter of miles... maybe it wasn't my radiator at all!!!! Maybe it was my damned thermostat not opening!!!! So I might have been through 3 radiators, and two fans, all for nothing???
Here's the corresponding pic. I don't need to tell you which one failed.
So anyways... now I have this boiling pot, and two near identical Mr. Gasket thermostats. Once the water reaches 190*, I drop them in! Instantly, the old thermostat opens right up, completely open like it should. The NEW one however... wouldn't open up a crack! I let it sit for about 5 minutes, and no opening.
So this pisses me off. I'd expect a good product from a company like Mr. Gasket. I would think something as simple as a thermostat shouldn't have any issues. I know outsourcing is the rage now... but come on... they can't even build a decent thermostat that opens when it should? So now I'm thinking... my whole overheating issue before... where I'd reach 240* in a matter of miles... maybe it wasn't my radiator at all!!!! Maybe it was my damned thermostat not opening!!!! So I might have been through 3 radiators, and two fans, all for nothing???
Here's the corresponding pic. I don't need to tell you which one failed.